An employee got a new phone: how to reset their MFA safely
Resetting a staff member's MFA in Microsoft 365 is a favorite trick of attackers. How to verify the request, reset it properly and check afterwards.
"I got a new phone and now I can't sign in." In a business using Microsoft 365 with multifactor authentication (MFA), this is one of the most common requests an office manager or IT contact receives. It is also one of the most abused. Resetting someone's MFA hands the account to whoever is on the other end of the call, so the way you handle it matters as much as having MFA in the first place.

Why this request is a target
Attackers who have stolen a password still face the MFA prompt. The easiest way around it is to ask for a reset. A joint CISA and FBI advisory on the Scattered Spider group described exactly this: criminals phoning help desks, posing as employees, and talking staff into resetting passwords and MFA. Small businesses are not exempt. A caller who sounds stressed, says they are traveling or with a client, and pushes for speed is following a script that works.
Step 1: confirm who is asking
Agree on a rule now, before it is needed: no MFA reset based only on an incoming call, text or email. Instead, use one of these:
- Call back on a number you already have on file for that person, not one they give you in the request.
- Confirm in person or on a video call where you can see them, if they are in the office or well known to you.
- Get their manager to confirm through a separate channel, such as a message from the manager's own account.
Security questions based on facts anyone can find online, like a start date or a manager's name, do not count. Write the rule down so whoever covers for you on holiday follows it too.
Step 2: reset the right way in Microsoft 365
An administrator does this in the Microsoft Entra admin center (or from the user's page in the Microsoft 365 admin center) under the user's Authentication methods:
- Remove the old method that belonged to the lost or replaced phone, such as the Microsoft Authenticator registration or the old phone number.
- Use "Require re-register multifactor authentication" so the user is asked to set up MFA again at their next sign-in.
- Consider a Temporary Access Pass. If your tenant has it enabled, this gives the user a time-limited passcode to sign in once and register their new phone, which is safer than temporarily switching MFA off. Give the passcode only through the verified channel from step 1.
- If the old phone was lost or stolen rather than replaced, also revoke the user's sessions so anything signed in on that phone is logged out, and follow your process for a lost device.
Never "temporarily disable" MFA for the account, and never leave it in a state where anyone who signs in first gets to register their own phone.
Step 3: check afterwards
Once the user is back in, take a minute to look at the account:
- Is there only one authenticator registered, and does it match the new phone the user describes?
- Do the recent sign-in logs show locations and devices you expect?
- Has anyone added new inbox rules that forward, move or delete email? This is a common sign that an account was taken over.
Tell the user what you reset, so if they did not actually ask for it, they can say so immediately.
Make it rarer
Staff can avoid most of these calls by moving MFA to a new phone before they wipe or trade in the old one; Microsoft Authenticator supports backing up and restoring accounts. Registering a second method, such as a hardware security key or a passkey, means a lost phone is an inconvenience instead of a lockout. When someone leaves the company, removing their methods is part of a proper Microsoft 365 offboarding.
How we can help
We can set up the verification rule, Temporary Access Pass and backup sign-in methods as part of our password and account security service, and handle resets for you as part of small business IT support. Call (213) 986-4855.